Saturday, December 28, 2013

THE ECONOMIC SITUATION OF THE TURKISH CYPRIOT COMMUNITY ACCORDING TO THE NEWSPAPERS OF THE FIRST HALF OF THE 20TH CENTURY


          When the British administration started in Cyprus on 22 June 1878 after more than 300 years of Ottoman sovereignty, the island was an underdeveloped country. One of the important innovations brought to Cyprus by the British was the press. The first newspaper was printed and published in Larnaca in August 1878. It was a weekly newspaper called “Cyprus/Kypros” and it published articles in English and Greek languages.

The first newspaper published in Cyprus by the Turkish Cypriots in Turkish was the weekly “Saded” which could appear only 16 issues in 1889 and it was supposed to be a paper which published mainly some announcements. It seems that no copies have survived up today.

            Two years later, “Zaman”, the second Turkish Cypriot weekly newspaper was published in 1891, again in Nicosia by the contributions of the Ottoman Reading House (“Kiraathane-i Osmani”) which established the first Turkish Cypriot printing house also. It was written in one of the articles published in 1892 in “Zaman” that the richness and the development of the Turkish Cypriot community would only be possible with the review of the cirriculum of the Turkish Cypriot schools.

Some writers who were supporting the Young Turks movement in Turkey left “Zaman” and published the “Kibris” newspaper in 1893. One of the main aims of this weekly newspaper was “to help our country, to teach affection for our country and to offer services to its education.” “Kibris” stressed that the most important embarrassment in the island was the backwardness of the education. It was a necessity to open new schools at the Islamic villages and to change their curriculum. The girls and the women should be educated too. (Kibris, 10 April 1893)

“Kibris” was the newspaper where the early articles were written about the economic situation of the Turkish Cypriot. There were complaints of the local British government which did not give the necessary support to the commerce and the agriculture. Therefore the industry could not develop. On the other hand the people did not show enough interest and support to these economical fields. There should be development of the production techniques and an increase in the production of some industries like agriculture, textile and tannery, saving the working hours and reducing the cost. Most of the people used to prefer buying European products, causing a decrease in Cypriot production.

A small number of Turkish Cypriot youth used to go abroad, mainly to Istanbul for higher education, but when they returned to the island, they preferred to work as civil servants or advocates. Only a few worked in the field of trade. The number of the Muslim traders and artisans was very limited and their standards were not perfect. The schools used to give religious education, rather than reading, writing, history, arithmetics and science. The graduates of the secondary school did not know these subjects like the Christian children.    

            An article in “Kibris” newspaper of 1894 (25 June) made an assessment of the situation in the island after 16 years of British administration as such: “Since the change of administration, the Moslems of the island deprived everything and they were left in misery. All of their rights were gone. They started to be represented in the Legislative Assembly according to the ratio of their population, 9 Greek Cypriots and 3 Turkish Cypriots. Year by year, our population declined. Poverty disseminated. The Muslim education collapsed. The doors for civil servants were closed. The Turkish Cypriot civil servants were sacked and the Greek Cypriots were employed instead, especially in the municipalities. The Turkish Cypriot policemen worked hard, but this was not appreciated.”

            Mehmet Faik Bey, who was a member of the Moslem Educational Commission, sent a report to the Ottoman Prime Minister, Halil Rifat Bey, dated 10 August 1896, accusing the British administration that the job opportunities for the Turkish Cypriot were limited and those who were educated had to immigrate to other Ottoman provinces. The unemployed youth in the island could not get married. The rural Turkish Cypriot population spoke Greek and they were illiterate, because of lack of elementary schools. Some even converted their religion into Christianity. New schools should be opened in the villages and a lyceum was a necessity in Nicosia. The Christian population was 164,191 and there were only 47,927 Muslims. After 10 years, the importance of the Moslems would be diminished.”

            In 1897 there were in Nicosia 30-40 Greek Cypriot tradesmen and the Turkish Cypriots had only 4-5 tradesmen with less business capacity, whereas during the Ottoman period, the trade was in the hands of the Moslems and gradually the Christians took it over.

            The problem of emigration of the unemployed Moslems continued also in the following years. “Mirat-i Zaman” newspaper wrote in 1907 (29 May): “Unless we are forced to do so, it is contrary to Sheria Laws to emigrate from the island. We have to try to increase our population, instead of reducing it. He has to learn hand skills and deal with commerce. Do not sit in the coffeeshops. Do not play backgammon, draughts or cards. Let’s work and earn money. Do not be servant, use servants.”

            In 1909 one can see the influence of the “Unity and Progress Society” (Ittihat ve Terakki Cemiyeti) also in Cyprus where evening schools were opened for education of the Moslem people. For example, the village teacher Hadji Sadik Efendi, gave the example of the Christian population in Cyprus when he spoke of the importance of education at the opening ceremony of such a school in Siliku of Limassol district. (Mirat-ı Zaman, 29 March 1909)

Dr.Hafiz Djemal, who was a progressive T/C doctor practicing in Istanbul, stayed in Cyprus from 1906 until 1909 and established a school for the youth where they were taught by Turkish and German masters various handskills like shoe-making, carpetry, ironsmith, book-binding and umbrella-repairing. He also opened an evening school for foreign languages like Greek, English Arabic, German and French. After two years of hard work, he had to leave the island under the pressure of the religious reactionaries.

Dr.Hafız Djemal wrote the following in his memoirs published in “Mirat-i Zaman” newspaper in 1909 (31 May): “The Turkish Cypriots lack education and artisanship. There is no Turkish Cypriot doctor, pharmacist or midwife with diploma in the villages or towns in Cyprus. The Turkish population of 60,000 persons are obliged to go to the Greek Cypriots in order to satisfy their needs in these fields. There are many Greek Cypriot advocates who can speak Greek, English, French, Turkish, but there are only a few Turkish Cypriot advocates who came to the island lately. The Turkish Cypriot make shamishi, yoghurt, muhallebi (pudding), sherbet, sahlep, tea, ice-cream or they are servants, transport-workers, farmers, workers. Those civil servants who earn more than one and half pounds monthly are all in Nicosia and a few in Paphos. Some are shoe-maker, unskilled gardeners, beys and aghas. Some grocers with small capital, barbers, clock-repairers. In the subject of national development, the Greek Cypriots are all in unity, cooperation and solidarity. The Turkish Cypriot cannot bear each other, they quarrel, entertain themselves continuously and they live day by day. 60% of them do not send their children to school. Some send, but they cannot be big personalities and professionals. We are 200 years backward than the Greek Cypriots.”      

Mustafa Hami Bey who served as a Turkish Cypriot member in the Legislative Council wrote a series of articles in the “Vatan” newspaper in 1911 (26 June) under the title “Our socio-economic problems” in which he tried to find an answer to the question: “Why can we not be rich?” His answer was: “Certainly, we don’t search for ways which can lead us to richness.” He also advised that secondary schools should be established for the girls.

Again in the same year of 1911, advocate Osman Djemal Efendi published a book with 46 pages called “Awakening” in which he wrote the following: “Since 30 years, we are struggling with the problems of education and vakıf properties. We could not reach to any conclusions. Those who are supposed to lead us, pose themselves as if they are patriots, nationalists, but after they are elected, they are lazy and opportunists. The Christians are inclined to opt for trade and artisanship, but the Moslems prefer to be civil servants and spend their money for entertainment.”

Mehmet Remzi wrote in “Dogru Yol” newspaper in 1920 (10 January) an article under the title “Those persons and nations who do not have self-confidence come under the sovereignty of those who are enterprizing and consistent” and proposed the establishment of a Turkish Cypriot commercial bank in Nicosia where there was only one Turkish Cypriot savings bank. The same newspaper wrote on the first anniversary of its publication in 1920 (13 August): “50 years ago, we were rich, but today we became poor. If you compare the level of our education 50 years ago with that of today, there is a slight difference which cannot be felt.”

“Davul”, a satirical newspaper of 1923 (1 April) gave the following report of the economical situation of the Turkish Cypriots: “The villagers are about to be drown in debt. All of their properties are given as mortgage to the rich Greek Cypriots. Our rich people try to hide themselves somewhere. In all villages illiteracy reigns, agriculture is being done in a very primitive way, commerce is all in the hands of the Greek Cypriots. There is no Turkish Cypriot artisan. Ironsmiths, shoe-makers, carpenters, in short, all branches of handwork are in the hands of the Greek Cypriots. We are either butchers or quilt-makers. What do we need more? The artisans who are masters, stay in Nicosia, they do not go outside… Nicosia is the town where the Turkish existence is felt mostly. Buildings rise to the sky in the Greek Cypriot quarters, whereas the Turkish Cypriot quarters are like the hole of the mole, full of huts made of mud. Now I ask: Is it advanced or backward?”

Advocate Fadıl Niyazi wrote in “Birlik” newspaper in 1924 (25 January): “If we overview the life of the Moslems in our island, we shall see that the farms, money and ready earnings of our ancestors are gone into history. We inherited from them big wealth and it is gone away in half a century. Today we have to work hard in order to live… We have three fields in the island to work in: Agriculture, Artisanship and Trade. They constitute the three legs of our national existence.”     

The first issue of the “Haber” newspaper published in 1934 (20 October) reported: “Although a lot of years have passed away, there is a field where we could not enter: The field of money-earning… The road of progress for us could only give way when we enter this field.”

One year later in 1935 (3 October), the “Ses” newspaper underlined again in its editorial under the title “Our Situation” the importance of trade and artisanship which was emphasized before by Dr.Hafiz Djemal and other T/C newspapers like “Masum Millet” of Advocate J.Rifat Bey. It was the duty of the Turkish Cypriot leaders to ask for the foundation of one school for commerce and one for handwork. The same newspaper paid attention to the importance of industrialization in Cyprus which was being developed by the Greek Cypriots and Armenians. It was reported that it was a pity not to have any Turkish Cypriot member in the executive committee of the Cypriot Chamber of Commerce in March (5) 1936.

In 1936 (30 July), “Soz” newspaper stated that in Turkey many industries were built by the banks, whereas in Cyprus there had to be a Turkish Cypriot commercial bank which would lay foundation for the Turkish Cypriot factory. In 1938 (5 April and 10 May), Nedjati Ozkan, an ex-MP, established some companies of his own: a cigarette factory, a shipping agency, timberwork, mosaic factory.

In 1943 (29 June) , the daily newspaper “Halkin Sesi” reported that there were 5 G/C cigarette factories which used 17,500 okes of tobacco, whereas Nedjati’s factory could only use 13 okes of tobacco, making 520 packets of cigarettes.     

The weekly “Yanki” newspaper complained in 1945: “We showed great incapability and lost our national wealth which worthed fortunes. We became weak and poor. We handed over the markets full of Turkish tradesmen to the competing element. We can express it with one sentence: We were masters and we became servants and nothing. Because we could not adopt ourselves to the innovations of the time. We are without organizations. We established the (political party) KATAK, but our co-founder friends tried to destroy it with their heavy critics.”

Riza Burcak wrote in Soz newspaper in 1946 (11 January) in a serial of articles under the title “The reasons of our backwardness”. The reasons were given as having no ideas and the mentality of a civil servant. He advised the readers to enterprize into the commercial life.

Advocate J.M.Rifat, publisher of “Masum Millet”, wrote the following in the first issue of the journal called “Yeni Fikirler” (May 1946): “The endeavour of Dr.Hafiz Djemal Bey was rejected in 1904 when he wanted to bring the polytechnical education into the country… There is no need for the masses of civil servants and teachers.”

As it is recorded above the Turkish Cypriots are away from a productive life since the beginning of the 1900’s. They are outside the economical life and stayed as consumers.

M.Kemal Deniz was happy to write at the end of 1946 (6 December) in daily newspaper “Ates” that recently some Turkish Cypriots entered into commercial life. He gave as examples the “Turkish Cinema Company”, the commercial companies like “Atai Brothers”, “Halil Ali and Sons”.

A columnist called “Gurses” was still stressing in 1947 (7 September) in the daily newspaper “Ates” that the Turkish Cypriots should try to develop themselves in the field of economy. They should stop going to the cinemas, entertainment places like bars and gambling-houses which were enemies of money.    

In 1947 (11, 12, 13 June) “Hursoz” daily newspaper published a series of articles written by the pharmacist H.Timur Azmioglu under the title “The situation of the Turkish Cypriots in the economy, handwork and commerce”.

“Halkin Sesi” newspaper published (29 April 1948) award-winning article called “Why did we stay backward in the social field?”

The weekly newspaper “Kurun” reported (1 May 1948) about a discussion of the pupils at the first class of the Lyceum under the subject: “To be a civil servant or a free-lance professional?”

In the same year 1948 (19 May), “Emekci” newspaper was published in support of the miners on strike, complaining that the workers were not organized. “Emekci” wrote in its first issue: “The Turkish Cypriots are today a mass of villagers and farmers without a plot of land and the labourers working in the towns and cities as miners and dock workers. They do not have a team of tradesmen and factory-owners, forming a class of businessmen.” 

Irfan Huseyin was arguing in his editorial in the “Turk Sozu” newspaper in 1948 (9 July) under the title “Our Economic Claims”: “As the Jews grabbed the economy, the Arabs were sleeping.Where are our enterprizing men? Ledra Palace could be built by a Turkish Cypriot company, instead of a Greek Cypriot one. Our many doctors could come together and establish a hospital.”

Finally in 1950 (15 November), one could read the following in “Istiklal” newspaper of Nedjati Ozkan, under the title “A Turkish Cypriot Market of which we can be proud”: “In the Medjidiye Street (of Nicosia), there are furniture-makers, tailors, shoe-makers, pharmacies, importers, confectionaries, upholsterers, the Turkish Bank, Istiklal newspaper and its printing-house, Turkish State Airlines and Railways, Guven Insurance Company, booksellers, book-binder, curiosity shop, taxi-office, bicycle-repairer, barber, grocer, the club “Kardes Ocagı”, accountant’s office.”

The Turkish Cypriots were now able to speak of a market of their own.    

 
(This paper was read at the 6th session of an international conference, organized by the Turkish Studies Department of the University of Cyprus in Nicosia, on 20 May 2004, under the title “History of Press in the Middle East: Economics as a subject in the Middle East Press)

No comments:

Post a Comment